Pandemic Pages

Pandemic Pages

Pandemic Pages

Published in English Journal, September 2021, Volume 111.1 
reprinted here without sidebars

I started my first semester of student teaching at an independent school in New York City, on a Thursday morning in September of 2001. The following Tuesday, seven subway stops from my classroom, terrorists attacked the World Trade Center, killing 2,977 people.

The 13/14s, as Bank Street School for Children calls its eighth graders, had begun a semester-long study of ancient Greece and the Classics. But I felt compelled, with support from faculty, to develop a series of lessons that spoke to the immediate crisis. “Finding Poetry in Tragedy,” the name of the unit, introduced students to historic examples of art created from the ashes of anguish — Homer’s Iliad, Picasso’s Guernica, Maya Lin’s Memorial Wall — then instructed them to assemble found poems from present-day newspaper clippings. Students were required to submit, along with their final poems, process paragraphs explaining their poetic choices (meter, rhyme, form, and so forth) as well as reflections on their experience of the project, both intellectually and emotionally. The unit spanned two weeks and culminated in a salon-style poetry reading. It proved illuminating and generative, for some students, cathartic. 

Back home in New Jersey, my own children, then twelve and ten, had spent the day on 9/11 nervously awaiting news of their father, who worked at the World Trade Center. Mark had just entered the second tower, at 8:46 that morning, when the first plane hit. He, thankfully, survived, but our children would go on to dream about the attack, they would talk about it in therapy, they would write about it in their college essays. Their friends, some of whom had lost a parent or relative in the bombing, voiced similar experiences. Like other national catastrophes — the Depression, World War II, the Vietnam War — 9/11 would come to define a generation. 

The same will be true of the pandemic.  

Facemasks, quarantine, lockdown, social distancing, daily death tolls that far exceed the fatality count at Ground Zero — the pandemic is shaping our students and our children in ways we have yet to understand. But the message to educators is clear. While teachers and students have risen to the challenges of remote learning, gaining dexterity on Zoom, Google Classroom, and other virtual platforms, our courses of study remain much the same. I believe the content of what we teach, not just the container for how we teach it, must adapt to the terror and tumult of the times.

I have been teaching memoir writing in adult education for twenty years. Last spring, I was contracted to teach my signature course, Writing Womanhood, at a community college in northern California where I now live. Eighteen women signed up. Two weeks before the start of class, however, I tested positive for COVID-19. Mine was one of the first cases reported in my county, the very first among my personal and professional circles. With advice from the chancellor of the college, we canceled my course without explanation. 

Stephen King famously said that writing, once a way of life, became his way back to life the summer he was hit and nearly killed by an errant car on a country road (King 249). Writing saved me, too. Feverish and afraid, I opened my notebook and started writing. I wrote about the day, in early March, when my husband and I flew from San Francisco to New York City for my nephew’s wedding, how we were up in the air, midway across the country, when the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 a pandemic. I wrote about the afternoon, soon after we returned home, when Mark began to cough and I followed him around with a spray bottle (two teaspoons of bleach diluted in sixteen ounces of water), wiping every surface he touched. I wrote about the morning my eggs tasted like sodium, and my coffee smelled like sulfur. I wrote about the different ways our children rallied to our aid, our son putting into place an emergency protocol, our daughter depositing on our doorstep food and supplements known to support respiration and boost immunity. I wrote about our daily telephone calls with Nurse D from the local health services agency, the gratitude I felt knowing someone was out there, watching over us. From the day my sense of taste and smell went missing until now when it has yet fully to recover, writing has been a lifeline; my notebook has kept me afloat.

In July, recalling the unit I had developed in the wake of 9/11, I began teaching a virtual “writing together apart” workshop called Pandemic Pages. Part writing class, part restorative retreat, the five-week course directs students to document in a “pandemic notebook” the ordinary details of these extraordinary days. The twentieth-century poet Gwendolyn Brooks, the first African American author to win the Pulitzer Prize, insisted that writers collect words. “The more words you know,” she said, “the better you will be able to express yourself, your thoughts” (qtd in Heard 48). And so our first task is to create a “pandemic dictionary” — complete with etymologies and definitions, both real and made up, of all the words that have been invented, reclaimed, and reimagined to describe this indescribable moment: mask up, unmute, shelter in place, flatten the curve, anosmia, super spreader, essential worker, herd immunity, Zoom fog, long hauler (Goldberg). With heartbreak and humor, we immerse ourselves in the language of the pandemic.

Pandemic Pages begins by inviting students to reflect back on their lives before the pandemic started, generating a list of “remember whens,” and the course ends by asking students to look ahead to the day the coronavirus recedes, filling in the first week of their post-pandemic calendar (Gondelman). In between, we situate ourselves exactly where we are now — which, for most of us, is home. We prime our pens with a series of quick-writes called “postcards from home,” an activity inspired by the work of artist and graphic novelist Aidan Koch (Koch). We go on to write about what we eat and what we wear (our pandemic pantries and COVID closets). We write about how we work and study, exercise and socialize — all the creative and compromised ways we’ve been passing the time (Smith 23). We write about loneliness and fear (note that the word pandemic derives from the same Greek root as the words panic and pandemonium). Along the way, we examine newly published essays, poems, art, photographs, and podcasts as inspiration for writing, and we share our writing in small breakouts.

Wallace Stegner once described writing as a social act. “It is also,” he said, “at its best, an affirmation — a way of joining the human race” (Stegner 66).  In that spirit, we gather on our final day for an all-class reading of our writing, “Voices from the Pandemic.” Sally reads a story titled “Home in Three Acts.” Behnaz describes the view from her window. Victoria recounts an encounter with an anti-masker. Kayla recites a rhyming poem, “Pandemic Blues,” in which languor dissolves into laughter. Xenia reads a lyrical narrative about longing. Together and apart, we share our collective stories, and in so doing we begin to heal ourselves, one another, and the earth.

The great neurologist and author Oliver Sacks, a few months before he died, looked up from his notepad one evening and said to his partner Bill Hayes, “The most we can do is to write —intelligently, creatively, critically, evocatively — about what it is like living in the world at this time” (qtd in Hayes 13).

The year was 2015. Those words could not be more relevant today.

My parents, both Jews, came of age during the Second World War, and so I grew up hearing about the horrors of the Holocaust. My children, now thirty-two and thirty, will soon have children of their own. I wonder what these yet-to-be-born beings will know of the pandemic. What words will last? Which behaviors will persist? What fears — and hopes — will linger? What stories will we tell them? For now, all we can do is what every generation has done before us, and what every generation will do after us: lift ourselves out of the ashes of anguish and spin tragedy into poetry.

 



Works Cited 

 

Brooks, Gwendolyn. The Place My Words Are Looking For. Edited by Paul Janecsko. New York: Bradbury, 1990.

Goldberg, Emma. “The New Words for Our New Misery.” The New York Times. December 24, 2020: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/24/opinion/coronavirus-language-words.html.

Gondelman, Josh. “When It’s Safe: The First Week of My Post-Pandemic Social Calendar.” The New York Times. August 14, 2020: https://www.newyorker.com/humor/daily-shouts/when-its-safe-the-first-week-of-my-post-pandemic-social-calendar.

Hayes, Bill. How We Live Now: Scenes from the Pandemic. London: Bloomsbury, 2020.

Heard, Georgia. Writing toward Home: Tales and Lessons to Find Your Way. Portsmouth: Heinemann, 1995.

King, Stephen. On Writing: A Memoir of the Craft. New York: Pocket Books, 2000.

Koch, Aidan. “Why You Should Write Postcards, Even from Home.” The New York Times. August 7, 2020: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/07/arts/aidan-koch-postcards.html.

Smith, Zadie. Intimations. New York: Penguin Books, 2020.

Stegner, Wallace. On Teaching and Writing Fiction. New York: Penguin Books, 2002.