Essay
Porch Talk: Reading Their Eyes Were Watching God
Published in English Journal, September 2003, Volume 93.1 Winner of the Paul and Kate Palmer Writing Award Reprinted here without figures and sidebars
Every teacher knows the magic of casting a story net on the classroom. Tell a good story and all eyes are on you, all faces expectant, all voices hushed. But once the students have stopped talking, how do you get them to begin again? How do you harness the enchantment of storytelling in day-to-day talk about shared texts? In a fast-paced unit on Their Eyes Were Watching God, my eleventh-grade honors students sat on the porch with the characters from Zora Neale Hurston’s novel, listening and talking, eavesdropping and storytelling. In short, they used their ears and their mouths to read Their Eyes.
A Story about Storytelling
Their Eyes Were Watching God is, on one level, a story about storytelling. When Janie Crawford returns after a two-year absence to her home in Eatonville, Florida, she eagerly tells her story to her best friend Pheoby Watson. A classic frame, Janie’s life story spans nearly forty years but is told during an evening visit between the two friends on the steps of Janie’s back porch. At times, Janie speaks in her own voice; at times, she lets other characters speak for themselves. But for the most part, Janie’s story is told by a third-person narrator who is, of course, controlled by the master storyteller herself, Zora Neale Hurston. Throughout the novel, the reader feels as though he or she were eavesdropping on the many storytellers who sit on the front and back porches of Janie’s life.
Zora Neale Hurston was as much an anthropologist as she was a novelist. After studying at Barnard College with the celebrated anthropologist Franz Boas, she traveled extensively throughout the southern United States and the Caribbean to gather folklore and record the patterns of speech of illiterate, rural people of African descent (Parini 153). Her methods were as unorthodox as the material she amassed. Writes Hurston scholar Carla Kalan, “Evidently, she cut an unusual figure — a single black woman driving her own car, toting a gun, sometimes passing for a bootlegger, offering prize money for the best stories and ‘lies’” (Kinzer 2). Not surprisingly, the novel she reputedly crafted in just seven weeks is laced with legends, superstitions, songs, tales, proverbs, and local lore about the weather, plants, and animals of the South.
Such a novel, born of folklore and rooted in the oral tradition of storytelling, begs to be heard and discussed in the English classroom. Rather than permit my students to be passive receptacles of Janie’s story, I invited them to pull up a chair and join in the Porch Talk. We started by tuning our ears to Janie’s dialect and ended by sharing our own stories in an all-class storytelling. In between, we listened to the novel on audiocassette; discussed it in Porch Groups; reflected on what we read and heard in our notebooks; responded to each other’s entries during Notebook Swaps; wove a Tapestry of Theme Threads from quotes gleaned from the novel; and, as preparation for our final Porch Talk, we welcomed a visiting storyteller who modeled the lost art for students as they prepared to tell their own stories. The unit spanned four weeks and consisted of fourteen one-hour class periods preceded by a one-day introductory lesson.
Stories from Home
To introduce the unit, I invited students to consider the ancient tradition of storytelling by asking, “Why do people tell stories?” Zach, one of the more scholarly students, said that people tell stories to educate and edify, and he pointed to the Bible as an example. Sarah, a creative writer, offered up the Greek myths as evidence of stories that immortalize humans or justify nature. Jared, who likes to provide comic relief in the classroom, said that stories are strictly for entertainment, and he mentioned ghost stories as among his favorites. I then asked, “Where do stories come from?” and students said that stories come from experience, books, parents, ancestors, history, friends, nature, fears, dreams, childhood, home.
The poet Georgia Heard believes that we must begin by telling stories from the home. I read aloud an excerpt from her memoir Writing toward Home:
Home is a blueprint of memory. I can draw it for you. Exactly which path went where. Where the creek curved. Where my sisters’ pet ducks are buried. Alexandria, Virginia. Thirty miles outside Washington, D.C. A place we moved to when I was eight, from Germany, where my father was stationed. Home is the smell of the wet undersides of leaves behind our house — an earthy rotting acrid smell — and the shadow patches of cool that crossed my face like cobwebs as I ran through the woods. It’s the smell of creek crayfish and thick mud after a storm, it’s jumping on rocks over the creek, sometimes getting my sneakers wet, it’s seeking the hiding crayfish. It’s the cool of the backyard in late afternoon. Laddie’s ticks. The gutters rushing with rain during a storm. The streetlight buzzing on and the bugs speeding around it like I imagine the planets orbiting around our sun. Something known like breath. Skin is a kind of home. (1)
We listed all the places the poet calls home: Alexandria, Virginia; Germany; the smell of wet leaves; creek crayfish; jumping over rocks; her dog; the gutters rushing with rain; breath; skin. Clearly, “home” does not have to be a place; it can be a smell, a feeling, a memory, a pet, a person. With this in mind, students then generated their own lists of the places they call home. These were as poetic as Heard’s: my grandmother’s lap, sleep-away camp in the Poconos, the brook behind my house, my maroon-and-white baseball uniform.
Although the students did not yet know it, the excerpt from Heard’s memoir speaks to a major theme in Their Eyes Were Watching God, one I adapted for the Leaving Home, Finding Home, Finding Self unit. This theme was especially pertinent to my second-semester juniors who, already knee-deep in the college admissions process, were about to embark on a journey similar to Janie’s as she travels from one home to another in search of her self. At this point, however, I was interested only in encouraging students to think of home as a source for stories and themselves as legitimate storytellers.
The final piece of the “into” lesson was an activity called Map Stories, borrowed from Bill Roorbach’s Writing Life Stories (20). On 18” x 24” pieces of newsprint, students drew a map of a neighborhood they call home, “the map [they’ve] already made in [their] heart,” as Georgia Heard advises (2). Some students sketched the block they live on; others drew their elementary school, sleep-away camp, their uncle’s farm. I prompted students to “color” their map with as much detail as possible: the names of the streets; the locations of shops, schools, bus stops; where their friends live; where the scary people live; the secret meeting places; the forbidden places. I allotted only fifteen minutes for students to complete their sketch so that they would not agonize over any artistic shortcomings.
Flannery O’Connor once said, “If nothing happens, it’s not a story” (qtd. in Roorback 24). So I asked students to circle the places on their map where something happened. They then “storied” their maps in small groups, listening for which stories fell flat and which ones came to life. Finally, students wrote the first line of a story that emerged from their map and went home with instructions to draft a map story. The objective was for students to begin telling stories from the text of their own lives, as does Janie Crawford, not to produce a polished piece.
The Story behind the Story
With students primed for storytelling, I began the next class by saying, “Let me tell you a story,” and it was as if the lights had dimmed and the curtain had risen. Counting on the mystique that naturally comes from stories loaded with missing persons, false identities, sketchy diagrams, abandoned cemeteries, and supernatural signs, I proceeded to tell the story of how Alice Walker journeyed to Florida in 1973 in search of the unmarked grave of Zora Neale Hurston. In the spirit of the novel, I let Walker speak by reading aloud an excerpt from her written account:
We drive past blocks of small, pastel-colored houses and turn right onto Seventeenth Street. At the very end, we reach a tall curving gate, with the words “Garden of Heavenly Rest” fading into the stone. I expected, from Mrs. Patterson’s small drawing, to find a small circle — which would have placed Zora’s grave five or ten paces from the road. But the “circle” is over an acre large and looks more like an abandoned field. Tall weeds choke the dirt road and scrape against the sides of the car. It doesn’t help either that I step out onto an active ant hill. (133-4)
I told my class that there, hidden beneath dried grasses, snakes, and sandspurs, Walker resurrected not only a gravestone but also the reputation of a major African American novelist, whose brief but flamboyant career ended in obscurity and poverty. By now, my students were not only enchanted; they were curious.
Tuning Our Ears to Their Eyes
Hurston’s fiction has been described by some critics as “written oral art” (Parini 152). How, then, can we as English teachers liberate the voices from the printed pages of Their Eyes Were Watching God? As with other texts thick with dialect, it is easier for students to begin by hearing the natural cadence of the spoken language than by struggling to decipher the invented spellings of the written word. This is especially true in a large class like mine, in which several students spoke English as a second language and several others were reluctant readers. I chose the audio production performed by Ruby Dee, whose versatility and authenticity bring to life the many voices in the novel.
After briefly introducing the characters and the context, I invited students to listen to a segment of the book on audiocassette, beginning two pages into Chapter 2 with the line, “Pheoby’s hungry listening helped Janie to tell her story” (Hurston 10). Together, the class attempted to make sense of what they had heard, asking questions such as, “Why does Nanny not trust Johnny Taylor? Why does she insist that Janie marry? How does Nanny’s idea of marrying Logan Killicks differ from Janie’s idea of love?” Once the class had grappled with these questions, I distributed the texts. This time students could read along as we listened to the passage again. Now the questions ran deeper. “Why does the vision of Logan Killicks desecrate the pear tree? What might the pear tree signify? What does Nanny mean when she calls black women ‘de mules uh de world’?”
Effortlessly, students were already gaining facility with the language of the book. Now the work began. First in pairs using their notebooks and then as a class using an overhead transparency, students documented a short lexicon of Janie’s dialect (see fig. 1). Throughout the unit, they expanded and consulted the list — and playfully recited from it — as they continued to encounter new and unfamiliar constructions. Later, they considered what might have been lost had Hurston written the novel in conventional English. By the end of their study, their ears were so well tuned to Janie’s dialect that they could not imagine it any other way. (A helpful discussion of “The Dialect Question” can be found in Bushman and Bushman’s Using Young Adult Literature in the English Classroom 107.)
By listening to the audiobook every few days, we never strayed far from the spoken language of the story. Teacher and writer Natalie Goldberg insists that her students stay close to an author’s original words. In Thunder and Lightning, she explains, “Often when we study a book a good portion of the time is spent reading parts aloud. I cannot tell you the tenderness that is evoked when adult students one after the other stand up and read their favorite parts. Everyone becomes attentive” (122). The same thing happens in high school, but how rarely do we take the time to read books aloud in English class, especially at the honors level! Listening to the novel on tape is one way, as Goldberg advises, “to stay close to the heat of the writer’s words” (122). From that energy, the story comes to life and discussion naturally combusts.
Porch Talk
The bell is still ringing and students have already begun talking about last night’s reading. Rashida is offended by the repeated use of the word colored and the depiction of the characters as stereotypically ignorant. Maggie cannot understand how Janie, a girl her age, could be forced to marry someone she doesn’t know or love. Then Miles groans, “Is this gonna be one of those ‘chick’ books?” Clearly, the class is ready to talk. But how can I direct the discussions to address individual concerns without digressing into a free-for-all? And how can I provide a platform on which every student will have a voice — all the more important in discussions about a book whose central concern is “finding a voice in which to articulate one’s story” (Parini 156).
That platform became the porch. In the novel, the porch is both the literal and the symbolic setting — the stage on which the characters perform and the place where Janie finds her voice. From the back porch of Janie’s home in Eatonville to the front porch of Joe Starks’s general store, the porch is the place for talk and storytelling, for power struggles and friendly banter, for picking the guitar and playing dice. In our classroom, then, the porch became the metaphor for how we talked about the novel. Like Hurston’s characters, my students sat on an imaginary porch “and passed around the pictures of their thoughts for others to look at and see” (48). Instead of book groups, they worked in Porch Groups; instead of book talk, they engaged in Porch Talk.
It is our first day of Porch Talk, and one volunteer from each Porch Group is modeling the discussion for the class in a “fishbowl.” Jon has agreed to be the facilitator; Annie, the log keeper; Megan, the time keeper. Bryan and Colette know they will need to volunteer for one of these jobs next time. On the overhead, I have illuminated the discussion script, which details today’s topic, the relevant chapters, the time limit, and two points of discussion with suggested questions (see fig. 2). Students are advised that they will be expected to craft their own discussion questions in the weeks ahead.
As facilitator, Jon skims the script and begins. “We’ve known Janie to be a dreamer and a romantic,” he reads. “How do Janie’s dreams differ from Nanny’s?” Mostly, Jon sticks to the script, but he is encouraged to skip a question or invite a student to interject his or her own. After ten minutes, Megan advises the group to move to the second point of discussion, Janie’s second dream as embodied by Joe Starks. Bryan challenges the legitimacy of Janie’s marriage to Joe given that she is still married to Logan. Colette questions Joe’s intentions with Janie; she fears he might be “just another bum.” The group ends by agreeing that the road Janie travels symbolizes the “road of life”; they predict that there will be many “forks ahead.” All the while, Annie fills out the discussion log, which she will hand in at the end of class (see fig. 3).
The discussion scripts modeled for students how to pose an intelligent, open-ended question and prompted them to refer to the original text when formulating a response — skills not all honors students have mastered even by the eleventh grade. As the unit progressed, however, I gradually weaned the class from the scripts and required students to craft their own questions, providing only the topic of the day. In the end, the discussion scripts served not as mandates but as models, not as crutches but as training wheels for students still learning how to talk about literature.
The Porch Groups met regularly throughout the unit. As befits a gathering on a porch, the atmosphere was casual; students felt free to lean back in their chairs or sit up on their desks. But because there was a time limit and an agenda, the conversations were charged. There was much head shaking, debate, and laughter.
Conversations on Paper: The Notebook Swap
In keeping with the theme of the unit, Leaving Home, Finding Home, Finding Self, I encouraged students to think of their notebooks as a “home” for written reflections. Beginning with the map stories, students completed a variety of take-home and in-class writings that asked them to explore issues of theme, character, language, and structure. Later on, they used their notebooks to draft a personal story for the final all-class storytelling. The notebooks gave me insight into each student’s journey with the novel. They also provided me with an essential tool for assessment in a unit that produced more oral than written output.
The notebooks were more than just a home for private reflection, however. They provided another forum for dialogue. Periodically throughout the unit, the class held a Notebook Swap, during which members of each Porch Group responded in writing to one another’s entries. A variation of the dialogue journal described in Inside Out (Kirby, Liner, and Vinz 63), the Notebook Swap gave students a chance to conduct silent conversations on paper. Original entries were written only on the right-hand pages so that students could write their responses on the adjacent left-hand pages. “Visitors” to someone else’s notebook were advised to behave the way a houseguest would: courteously, respectfully, and neatly. The objective was not to critique or judge one another’s writing, but rather to provide another context — a safer and more private one — for students to talk about the text between themselves.
Tapestry of Theme Threads
Like all master storytellers, Zora Neale Hurston weaves themes into her novel like threads in a tapestry. Home, voice, dreams, love and marriage, journeys, power, freedom, stories — these recurring themes not only provided the focus of discussion during Porch Talk; they also inspired students to weave their own Tapestry of Theme Threads. It began as a large bulletin board with two gaping eyes. At the top of the Tapestry, I mounted ten themes, from which I hung long pieces of yarn. As students read the novel, they copied passages onto 3” x 5” index cards that related to each of the themes (see fig. 4). Students were required to identify the theme, copy the quotation, provide proper citation, give the context (who is speaking and what is happening) and explain the relevance (how the quote relates to the theme). By the end of the unit, our Tapestry was filled with theme cards. Students often hovered around the board, reading one another’s cards or gesturing to a particular card as “proof” of a point. While it kept students close to the original language of the novel, the Tapestry became another site for conversation.
A Classroom of Storytellers
As Janie Crawford nears the end of her story, the class began preparations for our final Porch Talk, an all-class telling of personal stories inspired by the novel. To help students find their stories, I asked them to make a list of all the stories they had been told, or all the stories they tell repeatedly (Goldberg, Bones 78). I then asked students to circle those stories that spoke to a theme on our Tapestry of Theme Threads. Dillon’s story about his brother’s beer belly did not fit, but Jared’s story of his grandfather’s escape from Germany during the Holocaust related to any number of themes. Several students revisited the map story they had written at the start of the unit.
We also welcomed to class a visiting storyteller, Mr. McKeon, who teaches Myth, Legend, and Bible at the high school. He chose to tell the story of a legendary slave hero mentioned in Hurston’s novel, Big John de Conquer, adapted from an African American folktale in The People Could Fly (Hamilton 107). Mr. McKeon is skilled at using the resources of a professional storyteller: varied tempo and pacing, visual images, repetition, silence, hand gestures, facial expressions, character voices, and audience participation. Students were captivated by the story and its delivery. “I noticed Mr. McKeon stood up at the climax,” Courtney said, “when the devil almost got John.” Blake was impressed that Mr. McKeon had “memorized the whole thing” but relieved to learn that he had improvised some parts on the spot.
Using Mr. McKeon’s performance as a model, students rehearsed their stories in pairs. Annie chose a story, now a family legend, of an ancestor who nearly drowned in Matawan Creek. Jon told the story of a harrowing pursuit that ended in a close escape from the Ho-ho-kus police. Kim, who did not want to share a personal story, told a Korean folktale that had been passed down from her great-grandparents. As they listened, students identified the key elements of each other’s stories (character, setting, conflict, resolution, beginning, and ending) and suggested performance techniques.
Finally, the big day arrived. Students had already received formal invitations to the Porch Talk that required them to RSVP in advance, and they had written and submitted a Story Abstract (see fig. 5). As students walked into the classroom, they were directed to one of several groupings of chairs — the Front Porch, Back Porch, or Side Porch — and invited to help themselves to pink lemonade and butter cookies. African American folk music played in the background. Several visitors attended, including the principal of our high school.
I began by connecting our storytelling to the storytelling in Hurston’s novel. By framing the story of Janie Crawford on a porch, I told the class, the author underscores the importance of the oral tradition of storytelling. Borrowing Hurston’s recurring metaphor of the mule as representative of the burden of African American women, I suggested that the storyteller, too, is a kind of mule, a tribal pack animal who carries her people’s stories from one generation to the next. I told students that they had come to class carrying a story that in some way spoke to a theme from the novel. I then invited them to “kick up [their] feet and join in the Porch Talk!” And so, like the novel itself, we began and ended in the same place, with students telling their stories.
Works Cited
Bushman, John H., and Kay Parks Bushman. Using Young Adult Literature in the English Classroom. 2nd ed. Upper Saddle River: Merrill, 1997.
Dee, Ruby, perf. Their Eyes Were Watching God. Audiocassette. Caedmon, 2000.
Goldberg, Natalie. Thunder and Lightning: Cracking Open the Writer’s Craft. New York: Bantam, 2000.
________. Writing Down the Bones: Freeing the Writer Within. Boston: Shambhala, l986.
Hamilton, Virginia. The People Could Fly: American Black Folktalkes. New York: Knopf, 1985.
Heard, Georgia. Writing toward Home: Tales and Lessons to Find Your Way. Portsmouth: Heinemann, 1995.
Hurston, Zora Neale. Their Eyes Were Watching God. New York: Harper, 1990.
Kinzer, Stephen. “Florida Footsteps of a Harlem Great.” New York Times. 9 May 2022: E1+.
Kirby, Dan, Tom Liner, and Ruth Vinz. Inside Out: Developmental Strategies for Teaching Writing. 2nd ed. Portsmouth: Boynton/Cook, 1988.
Parini, Jay, ed. “Zora Neale Hurston.” American Writers: A Collection of Literary Biographies. Supplement VI. New York: Scribner’s, 2001. 149 – 161.
Roorbach, Bill. Writing Life Stories. Cincinnati: Story, 1998.
Walker, Alice. In Search of Our Mothers’ Gardens. San Diego: Harvest, 1983.